San Clemente Council Approves Controversial Hotel Plan with Rooftop Deck

UPDATE: The San Clemente City Council has just approved a contentious plan for a new four-story boutique hotel featuring a rooftop deck, raising concerns among local residents about noise and environmental impacts. This decision is aimed at having the hotel ready for visitors during the 2028 Los Angeles Olympics and the anticipated surfing competition at nearby Lower Trestles.

The project, known as The Lodge at San Clemente, is set to occupy a vacant 2-acre parcel along Avenida Vista Hermosa, directly across from the Outlets at San Clemente and adjacent to senior housing. The hotel plan was originally approved in 2004 but has faced delays and changes, including a recent height increase from 45 feet to 62 feet to accommodate the rooftop deck and elevator towers.

Residents have expressed significant discontent over the taller hotel, fearing increased noise and light pollution that could disrupt their quiet neighborhoods. Local advocate Beverly Wiesen has been vocal about these issues, stating, “We could choose to litigate and force that EIR, and what we’re trying to do is avoid that.” She emphasizes the need for mitigation measures on noise and light and insists on independent noise studies to protect community well-being.

In a recent council meeting, City Manager Andy Hall expressed optimism about finding common ground, suggesting a written agreement between the developer and residents to clarify expectations. “If we can enclose three walls and have a disappearing wall, we can contain the sound, especially in the evening hours,” Hall explained, highlighting the potential for compromise.

Architect Tim Fleming, who has met with Hall multiple times to discuss community concerns, acknowledged the importance of addressing noise issues. “We have discussed putting some of the bar inside and enclosing a portion of the roof deck that would acoustically benefit the community,” he said. He also reassured residents that measures to minimize light pollution are being considered.

The council’s decision to move forward without requiring a new environmental study has raised eyebrows. Wiesen and other residents are anxious that the council approved this without addressing crucial noise conditions. They are planning to meet again on November 3, 2023, to discuss their concerns further with Fleming present.

Mayor Steve Knoblock is confident a solution will be reached that benefits both the hotel project and the community. “The goal is to have it for the 2028 Olympics; that’s why we want to get it built,” he noted, emphasizing the economic boost the hotel could bring to San Clemente.

This developing story is indicative of the broader tensions between urban development and community interests, as cities seek to capitalize on upcoming events while residents fight to maintain their quality of life. Further updates are expected as discussions between stakeholders continue, and residents await assurances that their concerns will be addressed.

Stay tuned for more updates as this situation unfolds.