MLB Predictions Graded: Teams Face Mixed Results, Insights Revealed

UPDATE: In a thrilling recap of the 2025 MLB season, bold predictions made for all 30 teams have been graded, revealing a mix of triumphs and disappointments. As the baseball world gears up for the 2026 season, fans are eager to see how these forecasts stack up against reality.

NEW REPORTS CONFIRM that standout players like Paul Skenes of the Pittsburgh Pirates not only won the Cy Young Award but had one of the best seasons for a Pirates starter since 1920, scoring an impressive A+ grade. His remarkable 7.7 WAR and 1.97 ERA set a high bar, leaving fans wondering if he can exceed these numbers in the coming year.

Meanwhile, the Seattle Mariners‘ Bryan Woo also earned an A+, finishing the season with a stellar 15-7 record and a 2.94 ERA. His health will be crucial for the Mariners as they aim for their first World Series appearance in 2026 after falling just short this year.

However, not every prediction hit the mark. The New York Yankees were expected to finish with a losing record for the first time since 1992. Instead, they surprised everyone with a 94-win season, thanks largely to Aaron Judge‘s MVP performance and the unexpected contributions from Trent Grisham and Cody Bellinger. This miscalculation earned a dismal F grade.

On the other hand, the Baltimore Orioles faced challenges, with their prospect Samuel Basallo failing to live up to expectations, resulting in a D- grade for his performance. As he transitions into the major leagues, his future remains uncertain, keeping fans on edge about his potential breakout in 2026.

Fans were also left disappointed by predictions that Vladimir Guerrero Jr. would be traded. Instead, he signed a massive $500 million contract extension, solidifying his role with the Toronto Blue Jays and proving the initial forecast wildly inaccurate.

As teams prepare for the upcoming season, numerous players will look to bounce back from disappointing performances. The Los Angeles Angels and Chicago White Sox also saw their predictions fall short, with Angels hitters failing to deliver on power numbers despite leading the majors in home runs.

Looking ahead, fans are eager to see how these developments influence roster strategies and team dynamics as the 2026 MLB season approaches. The excitement is palpable as teams reassess their game plans, with several looking to make significant trades and acquisitions to enhance their rosters.

Stay tuned for more updates as teams finalize their preparations for what promises to be an exhilarating 2026 MLB season. The stakes are high, and fans are eager to see which teams will rise to the challenge and make an impact on the diamond.