Prosecutors Push for Joint Trial in Bailey Murder Case

UPDATE: Prosecutors have just announced their intent to pursue a joint trial for Ralph Stokes and Betty Ann Tomlinson in the shocking murder case of Jimmijion Bailey. This urgent development comes after Stokes, 24, of Gary, Indiana, was charged with the fatal shooting of his ex-girlfriend’s new boyfriend on October 5, 2024.

The heinous nature of this crime has sent shockwaves through the community. Bailey, just 25 years old, was discovered deceased on October 11, with his body bound and decapitated on the 2300 block of Clay Street. Prosecutors are arguing that a joint trial is essential, citing a “common scheme or plan” involving both defendants. They claim that the involvement of Tomlinson, the mother of Stokes’ ex-girlfriend, directly challenges Stokes’ defense of self-defense.

In court filings dated October 1, Deputy Prosecutors Eric Randall and Lindsey Lanham detailed how the pair’s actions were intertwined, stating that Tomlinson’s purchase of cleaning supplies and lighter fluid—two bottles bought from a Citgo gas station in the early morning hours of October 11—indicates collusion.

However, Stokes’ defense team, led by attorneys Lakeisha Murdaugh and Amishi Sanghvi, is fiercely opposing the joint trial. They argue that the defendants’ differing roles in the crime create significant potential for prejudice against Stokes, claiming that the evidence does not overlap and that they are not charged with the same offenses.

The defense asserts, “Ralph is not charged with concealing the body, cleaning the apartment, burning the apartment, or participating in the decapitation.” They emphasize that a joint trial would likely confuse jurors about the distinct actions and motivations of each defendant.

The impact of this case is profound, as family and friends of Bailey have expressed their grief and anger. Reports indicate that Bailey had only recently begun dating Stokes’ ex-girlfriend, igniting jealousy that may have led to this tragic incident. License plate reader data suggests Bailey arrived at the apartment on the night of the murder, with his vehicle being driven away afterward to obscure the crime.

Police investigations revealed alarming findings when they executed a search warrant at the girlfriend’s apartment on the 500 block of Vermillion Place. Officers noted an overpowering chemical odor and discovered multiple bottles of lighter fluid on the floor, alongside signs of attempted arson. Blood stains were also visible in the bedroom, indicating a violent struggle.

As authorities piece together this chilling case, a court hearing originally scheduled for this Wednesday has been rescheduled to November 25. As the trial approaches, the community remains on edge, awaiting justice for Jimmijion Bailey.

The stakes are high, with prosecutors determined to establish a link between the defendants that could influence the jury’s perspective. All eyes will be on the courtroom as developments unfold in this harrowing murder investigation.

Stay tuned for updates as this story continues to develop.