Elsbeth’s Episode “And Then There Were Nuns” Delivers Surprising Twists

The latest episode of *Elsbeth*, titled “And Then There Were Nuns,” aired on October 5, 2025, on CBS and is now available for streaming on Paramount+. This episode introduces a unique twist as it features Dianne Wiest in the role of Mother Constance, a nun who resorts to murder to save her convent. In a dramatic turn of events, she plots to eliminate pop star Alaïa Jane, leading to her fall from a bell tower.

The episode begins with an extended cold open, focusing on Mother Constance’s plan before Elsbeth, played by Carrie Preston, enters the scene. For over ten minutes, viewers witness Constance’s journey as she learns of the convent’s impending sale to Alaïa, watches an episode of the in-universe procedural *Father Crime*, and ultimately decides to take matters into her own hands. The premise sets the stage for a blend of humor and crime, drawing parallels to classic Agatha Christie stories.

Dianne Wiest’s portrayal of Mother Constance is a standout performance, balancing seriousness with the absurdity of her actions. Her character manipulates situations to execute her plan, showcasing a darkly comedic motive that resonates with viewers. The enclosed convent setting adds a layer of intrigue, making the episode feel reminiscent of a classic whodunit.

Fans of *Elsbeth* have noted the show’s signature humor, which contrasts sharply with the gravity of the crimes depicted. The episode cleverly combines elements of mystery and comedy, particularly as it explores the dynamics between the nun characters, each with distinct personalities beyond their habits. The return of Dominic Fumusa as Jack Wilson further enriches the narrative, providing a connection to the previous seasons while maintaining fresh storylines.

While the lengthy cold open may have felt unusual, it effectively establishes the context for the unfolding drama. As the plot progresses, Elsbeth’s investigative prowess comes into play, revealing the cracks in Mother Constance’s carefully crafted story. The episode culminates in a satisfying twist, showcasing the unintended consequences of the nun’s drastic actions.

Wiest’s performance, characterized by her ability to blend humor with menace, adds depth to the episode. Her character’s misguided intentions lead to an unexpected outcome, highlighting the absurdity of her choices. As viewers, we can’t help but appreciate the intricate storytelling that *Elsbeth* consistently delivers.

Looking ahead, “And Then There Were Nuns” is poised to be among the favorite episodes of the series, lauded for its clever writing and engaging performances. The show continues to captivate audiences with its unique blend of humor and crime, establishing a loyal fanbase eager for more.

As the series progresses, the intrigue surrounding characters like Alec Bloom raises questions about future developments. The subtle hints dropped in this episode suggest that *Elsbeth* is not merely a light-hearted comedy but a show willing to explore darker themes, making it all the more compelling.

New episodes of *Elsbeth* air Thursdays at 22:00 ET on CBS, typically following *Matlock*, which is currently on a brief hiatus. Viewers can catch up on previous episodes streaming on Paramount+.