New York’s Mayoral Elections Surge with Historic Wins and Shifts

UPDATE: New York’s mayoral elections have just concluded, delivering historic victories and significant political shifts across the state. On November 7, 2025, voters in upstate cities overwhelmingly chose new Democratic leaders, setting the stage for a dynamic political landscape as the state prepares for upcoming congressional and gubernatorial races.

Albany and Syracuse made headlines by electing their first Black mayors, both women: Dorcey Applyrs and Sharon Owens. Their victories reflect a continued Democratic dominance, with both securing over 70% of the vote. Meanwhile, Buffalo welcomed state Sen. Sean Ryan as its first new mayor in 20 years, while Rochester’s Malik Evans secured a second term.

These results are not just about new faces; they represent a substantial shift in local governance. The Democratic Party significantly increased its foothold, capturing local offices and defeating Republican incumbents throughout the state. In Onondaga County, Democrats appear poised to gain control of the county legislature for the first time in decades, a move that could alter the course of major infrastructure projects, including the upcoming Micron Technology semiconductor project.

The trend extended to Monroe County, where Democrats flipped five town seats, including Greece, where Jeffery McCann will become the first Democratic town supervisor in over a century. The city of Canandaigua also saw a surprising shift as Democrat Thomas Lyon defeated the Republican incumbent.

In a significant move, Democrats won all seats on the Troy City Council, flipping four Republican-held positions just two years after Carmella Mantello became the first Republican mayor since 2007. Tensions are already rising as the council grapples with the mayor’s controversial plan to relocate city hall.

Despite the Democratic surge, some Republicans achieved victories. Orange County Executive Steve Neuhaus secured a fourth term, while Nassau County and Rensselaer County saw Republican leaders maintain their positions. In Binghamton, Mayor Jared Kraham won decisively, and Saratoga Springs Republican Mayor John Safford leads his Democratic challenger.

The statewide ballot measure, allowing the Olympic Regional Development Authority to build on protected land near Lake Placid, is also a focal point. The proposal is narrowly passing with 46% in favor and 42% against, with over half a million voters leaving the question blank. This amendment aims to facilitate upgrades critical for world-class training while balancing land protection.

The political landscape is further complicated by the emergence of Zohran Mamdani as New York City’s new mayor. His election has energized Democratic strategies focusing on affordability, as highlighted by endorsements from state leaders like Governor Kathy Hochul and House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries. However, Republicans, including U.S. Rep. Elise Stefanik, are positioning Mamdani’s policies as a liability for Democrats, aiming to leverage this narrative in the upcoming midterms.

As New York navigates these unprecedented changes, the implications of the 2025 elections will resonate across the political spectrum. The focus now shifts to how these newly elected officials will address pressing issues and the potential ramifications for their parties heading into the next election cycle.

Stay tuned for more updates as we cover the unfolding political landscape across New York.