Witness Arrested for Perjury in High-Profile Liquor Case

On November 28, 1909, in Bismarck, North Dakota, a significant legal development unfolded as Mary Townsend, the principal witness in a liquor-related case, was arrested for perjury. This incident stemmed from her recantation of prior testimony against Guy Bolton, a well-known figure in the illicit liquor trade.

Details of the Case

The case revolved around allegations of operating a “blind pig,” a term used for illegal bars selling alcohol. Townsend had previously testified against Bolton, asserting that she had purchased beer from him. However, during her latest appearance in court, she flatly denied having made such a purchase, claiming instead that she had only paid for drayage and freight on some beer.

State’s Attorney Stevens initiated the perjury charges following Townsend’s contradictory statements. The prosecution argued that her testimony was crucial for securing a conviction against Bolton, and without it, the case would likely be dismissed. Judge Winchester subsequently dismissed the jury and set Townsend’s bail for perjury at $2,000.

Reactions and Implications

The courtroom drama captivated those present, creating a stir not just among attendees but throughout the city. Bolton, often referred to as one of the “kings of the piggers,” faced a precarious legal situation, now dependent on the testimony of a witness who had recanted her earlier claims.

Stevens indicated that he intended to pursue additional charges of subornation of perjury against others who may have influenced Townsend’s initial testimony. The situation highlighted the serious nature of perjury and the potential legal consequences for those involved in fabricating evidence.

This unfolding case illustrates the complexities of legal proceedings in the early 20th century, particularly regarding issues surrounding alcohol regulation. The implications of Townsend’s arrest extend beyond this particular case, raising questions about the integrity of witness testimonies in similar legal scenarios.